WITH THREE FLAVORS to choose from —
Roth, deductible or nondeductible — figuring out which IRA is best for
you can be confusing. So let me make this simple: If you qualify for a
Roth, this is almost always the way to go.
If your employer offers a 401(k) plan
with a match, you should always max it out before considering any type of
IRA. Any employer match, no matter how small, is an immediate ROI (return
on your investment). Let’s say for every dollar you contribute to your
401(k) your employer adds 50¢. That’s a 50% return, immediately. No
other investment is that good!
If you have more to save, a Roth will
typically give you the best bang for your buck. The reasons are simple and
the time to do it is early in your earning cycle. WHY? The opportunity to
contribute to a Roth ends when your earnings reach a certain threshold.
But if you get all of the Roth that is available, the benefits of
compounding continues and the other unique benefits of a Roth over a
traditional IRA are too good to be true. I personally believe that the
Government has not fully realized how good it REALLY is for the taxpayer.
You and I both know that "a good thing never lasts forever". One
day, I predict, the Roth will be revised to eliminate some of its finest
features.
WHY is a Roth better? Unlike traditional
IRAs (both tax-deductible and non-deductible), withdrawals from Roth IRAs
after age 59 1/2 aren't generally taxed. You pay your taxes on the front
end by contributing after-tax dollars. So Roth IRAs enable savers who
remain in the same income tax bracket at retirement to accumulate more
money than even tax-deductible IRAs do. However, unlike a traditional IRA
which is required to begin distributions when your reach 70½, the Roth
has no such requirement. Therefore, if your plans include leaving an
estate, you never have to take a distribution from your Roth. You can
leave it for your heirs, and theirs, and theirs…..Yes, tax free.
The theory behind deferring taxes on
retirement savings is based upon the precept that we will be in a lower
tax bracket when we retire than we are when we contribute. Now, I am NOT
saying I don’t recommend deferral because I do. But if we can pay tax on
$2,000 when we are young and have access to more than $110,000, tax free
30 years later — that’s a good deal!! That assumes 10% simple interest
compounded annually and no other contributions beyond the $2,000.
So, let’s say that you contribute
$2,000 each year for 10 years when your income has reached the limit for
making a Roth contribution but you leave the Roth in tact, until age 60.
Year |
Begin |
Contribution |
Growth |
Ending |
0 |
- |
2,000 |
200 |
2,200 |
1 |
2,200 |
2,000 |
420 |
4,620 |
2 |
4,620 |
2,000 |
662 |
7,282 |
3 |
7,282 |
2,000 |
928 |
10,210 |
4 |
10,210 |
2,000 |
1,221 |
13,431 |
5 |
13,431 |
2,000 |
1,543 |
16,974 |
6 |
16,974 |
2,000 |
1,897 |
20,872 |
7 |
20,872 |
2,000 |
2,287 |
25,159 |
8 |
25,159 |
2,000 |
2,716 |
29,875 |
9 |
29,875 |
2,000 |
3,187 |
35,062 |
10 |
35,062 |
2,000 |
3,706 |
40,769 |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
22,000 |
|
|
If after the initial period of
contribution, 10 years, you left the investment to grow tax deferred for
an additional 20 years. At a 10% annual return (and the market has
consistently returned 10% on average for an extended period, the following
table summarizes the results:
Year |
Begin |
Growth |
Ending |
11 |
40,769 |
4,077 |
44,845 |
12 |
44,845 |
4,485 |
49,330 |
13 |
49,330 |
4,933 |
54,263 |
14 |
54,263 |
5,426 |
59,689 |
15 |
59,689 |
5,969 |
65,658 |
16 |
65,658 |
6,566 |
72,224 |
17 |
72,224 |
7,222 |
79,446 |
18 |
79,446 |
7,945 |
87,391 |
19 |
87,391 |
8,739 |
96,130 |
20 |
96,130 |
9,613 |
105,743 |
21 |
105,743 |
10,574 |
116,317 |
22 |
116,317 |
11,632 |
127,949 |
23 |
127,949 |
12,795 |
140,744 |
24 |
140,744 |
14,074 |
154,819 |
25 |
154,819 |
15,482 |
170,300 |
26 |
170,300 |
17,030 |
187,330 |
27 |
187,330 |
18,733 |
206,064 |
28 |
206,064 |
20,606 |
226,670 |
29 |
226,670 |
22,667 |
249,337 |
30 |
249,337 |
24,934 |
274,271 |
Now assume that when contributions were
being made, you were in a 28% bracket. By making after tax contributions
to your Roth IRA, you paid Federal tax on the contribution in the amount
of $6,160. Assume further that you are in a 15% bracket when you retire
— HIGHLY UNLIKELY! The tax on $274,000 would be $41,140.58. But, there’s
more! Since many of us won’t need to draw upon our IRA to live, the Roth
can be left to satisfy estate planning issues while a traditional IRA must
be withdrawn at a prescribed rate, subject to tax, regardless of our need.
So you see, a Roth is a great tool for
those just starting out. If you would like more information on how a Roth
can fit into your financial planning, give me a call.
Go Back to the Top of the Page
|